top of page

Home  /  Practice Areas  /  Estate Planning and Probate  /  Will Contest Attorneys in Colorado

 

ESTATE PLANNING AND PROBATE

 

Will Contest Attorneys in Colorado

 

Representation of people challenging a will and people defending one, including heirs, beneficiaries and personal representatives, in Colorado probate proceedings. We evaluate whether the facts support a recognized ground before anything is filed, track the deadlines, and pursue a negotiated resolution or a decision by the court.

 

Schedule a consultationCall 720.439.2530

 

YOUR TEAM

 

Partners in this practice

 

Every dispute is handled by a partner. Pick the one whose work matches yours, or call and we will match you.

 

David R. BallView bio →Michael P. BarryView bio →

 

 

 

Call 720.439.2530 or schedule a consultation.

 

ESTATE PLANNING AND PROBATE

 

Who we help

 

  • A child or relative left out of a recent will
  • A beneficiary whose share changed late in a parent's life
  • An heir who believes a will was not signed properly or was replaced by a later document
  • A family member concerned that a caregiver or advisor influenced the will
  • A personal representative defending the will in court
  • A beneficiary named in the will who is facing a challenge

 

 

 

Grounds to Contest a Will in Colorado

 

A will is not invalid just because it seems unfair, and a parent may leave property unequally. The person offering the will must first make a basic showing that it was properly signed. After that, the person contesting the will has the burden of proving a recognized ground:

 

  • Lack of testamentary capacity. A person must be at least eighteen and of sound mind to make a will. The question is the person's capacity when the will was signed, not before or after.
  • Undue influence. Pressure or manipulation that overcomes the will maker's own judgment, so the will reflects someone else's wishes.
  • Fraud or duress. A will procured by deception or threats.
  • Mistake. In limited circumstances, an error in the making of the will.
  • Revocation. A later will or another act that revoked the will offered for probate.
  • Lack of testamentary intent. The document was not meant to be a will.

 

 

Undue Influence

 

Undue influence is a frequent ground and often the hardest to see from outside. It is usually proven through circumstances: a relationship of trust or dependence, isolation of the will maker, a beneficiary who arranged the lawyer or the signing, a sudden change from earlier plans, or a will maker in declining health.

 

When a beneficiary was in a fiduciary or confidential relationship with the will maker, Colorado law presumes undue influence, and the beneficiary must come forward with evidence to rebut it. The presumption shifts that burden of going forward, not the ultimate burden of proof, so the evidence on both sides still matters.

 

 

Will Signing Requirements

 

Colorado generally requires a will to be in writing, signed by the will maker, and either signed by two witnesses or acknowledged before a notary. A will that does not meet those requirements can still be valid as a handwritten will if the signature and the material portions are in the will maker's handwriting. Colorado also allows a court to treat a document as a valid will despite a defect in how it was witnessed or notarized, if the person signed or acknowledged it and clear and convincing evidence shows the person intended it to be their will.

 

Problems with signing, witnessing or a competing document are often where a contest starts. We review the original will, earlier wills and trusts, and how the will was prepared and signed.

 

 

Time Limits to Contest a Will

 

Timing is often the most important issue. When a will has been informally probated, a proceeding to contest it generally must be started within the later of twelve months after the informal probate or three years after the death. If the will was admitted in a formal proceeding and you received notice, your ability to object may be much more limited.

 

Many estates also pass through a revocable trust. A contest of a trust that was revocable at death must be brought within the earlier of three years after the death or 120 days after the trustee sent you a copy of the trust and the required notice, so a will contest and a trust contest can run on different clocks.

 

 

No Contest Clauses

 

Some wills include a clause that reduces or eliminates the share of anyone who contests the will. In Colorado, such a clause is unenforceable if probable cause existed for bringing the challenge. Whether probable cause exists depends on the evidence available when the contest is filed, which is another reason to investigate first.

 

 

Challenging or Defending a Will

 

We represent both sides. For people bringing a contest, we evaluate whether the facts support a recognized ground before anything is filed, because a weak contest costs time, money and family relationships. For personal representatives and beneficiaries defending a will, we gather the evidence of how and why the will was made and respond to the claims.

 

  • Reviewing earlier wills, trusts, beneficiary designations and changes to accounts or deeds
  • Obtaining medical records and statements from witnesses, the drafting attorney and caregivers
  • Filing or responding to the petition in a formal testacy proceeding
  • Discovery, depositions and work with medical and other professional witnesses

 

 

Settlement, Trial and Appeal

 

Many will contests resolve through negotiation or mediation, often with an agreement among the interested persons on how the estate will be divided. When a case does not settle, we take it to trial in probate court and handle post trial motions and appeals where appropriate. Related disputes over how the estate is run are covered on our Probate Litigation page.

 

 

Representative Matters

 

A selection of matters from our partners' work, described from their profiles.

 

 

David R. Ball

 

  • Litigated fiduciary and probate matters in small and large estates, including will challenges and inheritance rights.

 

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

 

 

If You Question a Will

 

  • Find out whether the will has been filed with the court and whether probate has started, and note the dates of any notice you received.
  • Gather earlier wills, letters and other documents that show what the person intended before.
  • Write down what you observed about the person's health, care and visitors in the months before the will was signed.
  • Do not sign a receipt, waiver or release from the personal representative before getting advice.
  • Talk with a lawyer promptly. The deadlines are strict and some cannot be extended.

 

Related services

 

Probate Litigation Attorneys in Colorado→Probate Administration Attorneys in Colorado→Wills Attorneys in Colorado→Trust Administration Attorneys in Colorado→

 

Talk to a partnerCall 720.439.2530 or schedule a consultation.Schedule a consultationDenver2701 Lawrence Street, Suite 101
Denver, CO 80205
Golden1120 Washington Ave., Suite 200
Golden, CO 80401

 

WORKING WITH US

 

How it works

 

01EvaluateWe review the will, earlier documents and the facts, and identify the possible grounds and the deadline that applies.02InvestigateWe gather medical records, financial records and witness accounts to test the claim or the defense before a petition is filed.03File or respondWe file the contest or the response in probate court and protect your position while the case proceeds, including asking the court to limit distributions where needed.04MediateMany contests settle at mediation once both sides have seen the evidence.

05ResolveIf the case does not settle, we try it in probate court and handle any appeal.

QUESTIONS

 

Frequently asked questions

 

 

Who can contest a will in Colorado?

 

Generally, an interested person whose inheritance would change if the will were set aside, such as an heir who would inherit without the will or a beneficiary under an earlier will. Whether you have standing depends on your relationship to the person who died and the documents involved.

 

 

 

How long do I have to contest a will in Colorado?

 

For a will that was informally probated, generally the later of twelve months after the informal probate or three years after the death. If the will went through formal probate with notice to you, the time to object may already have passed. Because the deadlines are strict, talk with a lawyer promptly.

 

 

 

Who has the burden of proof in a will contest?

 

The person offering the will must make a basic showing that it was properly signed. The person contesting the will then has the burden of proving lack of capacity or intent, undue influence, fraud, duress, mistake or revocation.

 

 

 

What is undue influence?

 

Undue influence is pressure or manipulation that overcomes the will maker's free judgment, so the will reflects someone else's wishes. It is often shown through circumstances, such as a relationship of trust, isolation of the will maker, or the beneficiary's involvement in preparing the will. The court looks at all of the facts.

 

 

 

What if the will was not signed correctly?

 

A will that lacks the required witnesses or notary can still be valid as a handwritten will, or, if the person signed or acknowledged it, when clear and convincing evidence shows the person intended the document to be their will. A signing defect is a reason to look closely, not always a reason the will fails.

 

 

 

Does a no contest clause stop me from challenging a will?

 

Not always. Under Colorado law, a will provision that penalizes a person for contesting the will is unenforceable if probable cause exists for the challenge. We review the facts before you decide whether to proceed.

 

 

Talk with
a partner.

 

Contact us for counsel that moves your business forward, not counsel that gets in the way.

 

Schedule a consultationCall 720.439.2530

 

 

DENVER
2701 Lawrence Street, Suite 101
Denver, CO 80205
GOLDEN
1120 Washington Ave., Suite 200
Golden, CO 80401
RECOGNITION

 

bottom of page